Review: Doctor's Orders


Well, that one was kinda cute, if low on Tucker and Reed. It was rather predictable, T'Pol was obviously just another figment of Phlox's imagination, but his dialogue with her was amusing. (I loved the bit about him actually having to read the operations manual for the warp drive, and his McCoy-ism in the same scene.)

The fact that the baby-version of the anomaly the ship encountered previously in "Harbinger" is capable of messing with everyone's neuro-whatevers so profoundly, convinces me that my theory explaining T'Pol's erm... seduction of Trip and Malcolm's extreme behaviour in regards to Hayes is correct. Both must have been caused by their brief immersion in the anomaly when the bridge was engulfed. It's the only explination I'll accept.

Anyway, enough of that. Back to "Doctor's Orders." I am becoming somewhat annoyed by the fact that the writers can't seem to decide if Phlox is physically and sexually shy, or a bit of an exhibitionist. In "Dear Doctor" we learn that Denobulans don't like casual physical contact, but here Phlox speaks fondly of how Denobulans prefer living packed together like biscuits in a barrel, wanders around the ship naked just 'cause no one is awake to see him do it, and doesn't seem to mind being jostled in the mess hall. This disjunct keeps popping up -- his (and his species') preferences change at the whim of the writers. I object. It's just plain sloppy. I wish that it was a phemomenon confined to Phlox, but I'm afraid it crops up in other characters as well. I don't mind having characters change - people do change - but it's usually over time. A gradual process, called growth. When people shift suddenly, and unpredictably from one extreme to another, it's called a personality disorder.

That's really my only Issue with the episode. Otherwise, it was pleasant, if predictable. A good brain break.

~RB







Enterprise and Star Trek are trademarks of Paramount. No infringement is intended. This fansite, and all of its content, is purely for the enjoyment of fans and is non-profit. That said, all fiction and graphics are copyright their respective authors/creators. If there are any problems with the site, contact the Webmistresses.